When it comes to grocery delivery, two giants often come to mind: Instacart and DoorDash. Both platforms have gained significant traction in recent years, but how do they stack up against each other? If you’re here, you’re likely looking for insights on which service will help you save time and potentially make a bit more money in your side hustle. I’ve navigated through both platforms, and I’ve got the lowdown for you.
Many people start with surveys because they’re easy to access, then gradually move on once they realise earnings are capped by availability and fixed payouts.
If you’re wondering what that next step usually looks like, this page breaks it down → See how it works.
Instacart Better Than Doordash: Which Choice Fits Your Situation
Instacart specializes in grocery delivery, partnering with local supermarkets to bring your favorite products directly to your doorstep. On the flip side, DoorDash started as a food delivery service but has expanded into grocery and convenience store deliveries. This evolution has led to a unique comparison of the two platforms. Are you looking for convenience, speed, or perhaps the best bang for your buck? Let’s dive into the details.
Understanding the differences between Instacart and DoorDash can help you make a more informed decision that aligns with your goals, whether you’re a busy parent, a college student, or simply someone who wants to avoid the grocery store chaos. Let’s break down what each platform offers and see which one might be better for your needs.
Quick Facts: Instacart vs. DoorDash
Here’s a snapshot of the two services to help you visualize the key differences right off the bat:
- Delivery Focus: Instacart focuses exclusively on groceries, while DoorDash has a broader menu that includes food from restaurants, convenience stores, and groceries.
- Delivery Fees: Instacart typically charges higher delivery fees, especially for smaller orders, whereas DoorDash often has promotions that can reduce or waive delivery fees.
- Delivery Speed: Instacart boasts same-day delivery, but DoorDash can deliver food from restaurants even quicker, sometimes in under 30 minutes.
- Membership Options: Instacart offers an Express membership for free delivery on orders over a certain amount, while DoorDash has DashPass for similar benefits.
- Payout Structure: Instacart shoppers earn based on a combination of hourly wage and tips, while DoorDash drivers (Dashers) primarily rely on tips and delivery fees.
What It Is: Understanding Each Platform
Instacart is all about grocery shopping. You log in, select your favorite items from various local supermarkets, and a personal shopper picks and packs your groceries for delivery. This service is ideal for those who prefer a one-stop shop for all their grocery needs without stepping foot in a store.
DoorDash initially catered to food delivery from local restaurants but has since branched out into grocery delivery. This means that while you can get groceries through DoorDash, the platform’s primary focus remains on restaurant food. This dual functionality can be a plus if you’re looking to combine your grocery and meal delivery needs into one app.
Both platforms offer mobile apps, making it easy to order from your smartphone. However, the user experience can vary significantly, with some finding Instacart’s interface more intuitive for grocery shopping, while others enjoy DoorDash’s broader selection of services.
How It Works: The Logistics Behind Each Service
Using Instacart is straightforward. After signing up, you enter your zip code, and from there, you can browse local stores. You add items to your cart, select a delivery window, and check out. Instacart assigns a shopper who picks your items and delivers them straight to your door. You can track your order in real-time, making it convenient to see when your groceries will arrive.
DoorDash operates similarly but with a few twists. After selecting your items, you place your order, and a Dasher accepts the delivery request. The Dasher then heads to the store or restaurant to pick up your items. The app allows you to track your Dasher’s progress, which is particularly useful if you’re waiting for a food delivery.
One thing to note is that both platforms have different pricing structures, which can impact your overall cost. For example, Instacart often has higher service fees for smaller orders, while DoorDash might incorporate surge pricing based on demand.
Feature Breakdown: What Each Service Offers
Instacart shines with its grocery-specific features. You can build shopping lists, reorder past purchases, and even receive personalized recommendations based on your shopping habits. Additionally, you can choose between multiple local grocery stores, which can sometimes lead to better prices or product availability.
DoorDash’s features are more diverse given its restaurant focus. You can schedule deliveries, customize meal options, and enjoy promotional offers on restaurant items. The integration of grocery delivery is a bonus, but it can feel secondary compared to its core function.
Both platforms offer user-friendly apps, but the experience may feel more streamlined on Instacart when grocery shopping. DoorDash, however, has added features like group orders, allowing multiple people to add to one delivery, which can be a great way to save on costs when ordering for friends or family.
Earnings Breakdown: Making Money with Each Platform
If you’re eyeing a side hustle, understanding how much you can earn on each platform is crucial. Instacart shoppers can expect to earn between $10 to $25 per hour, depending on factors like location and tips. The payout structure often includes a base pay plus tips, meaning your earnings can fluctuate significantly based on the generosity of your customers.
DoorDash drivers, or Dashers, typically earn between $2 to $10 per delivery, with tips potentially doubling their earnings. While the base pay may seem lower, the volume of deliveries you can complete in a short time can lead to a higher hourly wage. Plus, DoorDash frequently runs promotions that boost earnings during busy hours.
Let’s break this down with a quick scenario: Imagine you decide to work for Instacart. If you spend 3 hours shopping and delivering, and you earn $15 per hour, plus $10 in tips, you walk away with $55. Now, if you opted for DoorDash instead and completed 5 deliveries in that same time frame, earning $5 per delivery with an additional $20 in tips, your total would be $45. While Instacart looks better in this case, remember that your actual earnings can vary based on demand, location, and your efficiency.
| Platform | Hourly Earnings | Typical Delivery Time |
|---|---|---|
| Instacart | $10 – $25 | 45 – 60 minutes |
| DoorDash | $2 – $10 per delivery | 20 – 30 minutes |
Requirements: What You Need to Get Started
Getting started with either platform is relatively easy. For Instacart, you’ll need to be at least 18 years old, have a reliable method of transportation, and pass a background check. They also require that you have a smartphone to use the app, which is essential for managing orders and deliveries.
DoorDash has similar requirements. You must be at least 18, have a driver’s license, and pass a background check. Unlike Instacart, DoorDash allows delivery from bikes, scooters, or even walking in some urban areas, which can expand your options depending on where you live.
Both platforms require users to maintain a positive customer rating to continue receiving orders, which can be a challenge if you encounter a lot of difficult customers or are unable to meet delivery timelines. Keeping an eye on your performance metrics is crucial for continued success.
Limitations: The Downsides of Each Service
While both Instacart and DoorDash have their advantages, they come with limitations. Instacart shoppers often face challenges such as higher service fees and potential delays during peak shopping hours. If you’re not careful, you could end up spending more time waiting for orders to be filled than actually working.
DoorDash, on the other hand, can lead to frustrating experiences with low base pay and high competition among Dashers, especially during busy times. You might find yourself waiting longer for orders or struggling to get enough deliveries to make your time worthwhile.
Income ceilings are also a concern. While you can earn a decent side income, both platforms won’t replace a full-time job. If you’re looking for something more sustainable, you could quickly find yourself burnt out from the hustle without seeing the financial returns you hoped for.
Case Examples: Real User Experiences
Let’s consider a couple of real-world scenarios. Sarah, a busy mom, tries Instacart to save time. She finds that while it’s convenient, the delivery fees can add up, especially when she forgets to hit the minimum for free delivery. She enjoys the flexibility but struggles with the cost versus convenience balance.
Then there’s Tom, who works as a DoorDash driver. He enjoys the fast-paced nature of the gig but often feels frustrated by the inconsistency of earnings. Some nights he makes great money, while other nights he barely scrapes by. He appreciates the tips, but they can be hit or miss, depending on the customers.
Both Sarah and Tom illustrate the potential benefits and challenges of each platform. Depending on your lifestyle and financial goals, one might suit you better than the other.
Alternatives: What Else is Out There?
If neither Instacart nor DoorDash sounds like the right fit for you, there are alternative grocery delivery services worth considering. Services like Shipt offer a similar model to Instacart, focusing on grocery delivery from specific retailers. They operate on a membership basis, allowing for free delivery on orders over a certain amount.
For those looking for a more diverse delivery experience, consider Amazon Fresh, which combines grocery delivery with the convenience of shopping online. If you already have an Amazon Prime membership, this service could be a valuable add-on.
Who should switch? If you find yourself frustrated with the fees on Instacart, Shipt might be a better option. On the other hand, if you seek more flexibility and the chance to deliver food as well as groceries, sticking with DoorDash—or exploring Uber Eats—could be more beneficial.
FAQ: Common Questions Answered
Can you actually make money with Instacart or DoorDash?
Yes, you can earn money with both platforms, but how much depends on various factors such as location, time spent, and customer interactions. Instacart shoppers can expect to earn between $10 to $25 per hour, while DoorDash drivers can earn between $2 to $10 per delivery, plus tips.
How much can you realistically earn?
Realistically, if you work consistently, you might make anywhere from $200 to $800 per month, depending on how many hours you put in and the demand in your area. Keep in mind that these earnings can vary widely based on the time of day, location, and customer generosity.
Is Instacart worth it compared to DoorDash?
It depends on your needs. If you prefer grocery shopping and want a dedicated grocery delivery service, Instacart could be worth it. However, if you want flexibility and quicker delivery times, especially for food, DoorDash may be your better bet.
Final Thoughts: Making the Right Choice
Choosing between Instacart and DoorDash ultimately comes down to your personal needs and preferences. If grocery delivery is your primary concern, Instacart might be the way to go. However, if you’re looking for a broader range of delivery options, including restaurant food, DoorDash could be your best bet.
Both platforms can serve as great side hustles, offering flexibility and the potential to earn some extra cash. Just remember, neither will replace a full-time income, but they can help fill in the gaps when you need a little extra. Choose wisely based on what fits your lifestyle best, and you might just find that grocery delivery could be a rewarding venture.